Second Amendment Advocates Criticize DNC Platform As Gun Control Nightmare That’s ‘Blatantly Unconstitutional’

By: Sam Watanuki | Published: Aug 20, 2024

The 2024 Democratic National Committee (DNC) platform has sparked intense debate, particularly among Second Amendment advocates. Released just days before the DNC convention on August 19, the platform includes a range of proposed gun control measures.

Advocacy groups are now arguing that these proposals represent a direct threat to constitutional rights, setting the stage for a heated battle over the Second Amendment.

The Core Proposals of the DNC Platform

The DNC’s 2024 platform proposes several sweeping gun control regulations. These include a national red flag law, increased ATF funding for enforcement, and a renewed push for an assault weapons ban.

Advertisement
A close-up of a black gun with bullets beside it.

Source: Tom Def/Unsplash

The platform also seeks to ban high-capacity magazines, require safe gun storage, and strip liability protections from gun manufacturers—a move that has alarmed gun rights groups.

Gun Owners of America's Response

Gun Owners of America (GOA) has been particularly vocal in its opposition to the DNC platform. Aidan Johnston, GOA’s director of federal affairs, criticized the platform as being loaded with “blatantly unconstitutional policies.”

Advertisement
A group of people protesting in support of looser gun laws

Source: @GoadGatsby/X

He emphasized that the Second Amendment is “on the ballot” in this election, and GOA is preparing to push back through lobbying, campaign efforts, and potential legal challenges.

National Shooting Sports Foundation's Perspective

The National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) echoed GOA’s concerns, focusing on the proposed red flag laws. Mark Oliva, NSSF’s managing director for public affairs, argued that these laws lack protections for due process rights.

Advertisement
A person holding a gun while at a gun range.

Source: LOGAN WEAVER | @LGNWVR/Unsplash

He also warned that the DNC’s proposed increase in ATF funding could be used to target everyday gun owners and small businesses over minor infractions.

The Assault Weapons Ban Debate

The DNC’s platform includes a call for a renewed assault weapons ban, similar to the one enacted in 1994. However, critics argue that such a ban would likely be unconstitutional and difficult to enforce.

Advertisement
Gun shoppers browse through a large selection of assault rifles and handguns

Source: Getty Images

A 2024 RAND Corporation meta-analysis found that evidence on the effectiveness of assault weapons bans in reducing firearm-related homicides remains inconclusive, fueling further debate.

High-Capacity Magazine Ban Concerns

In addition to the assault weapons ban, the DNC platform advocates for banning high-capacity magazines. Opponents argue that this measure targets popular firearms used by law-abiding citizens for self-defense and recreation.

Advertisement
Gun bump stock on table

Source: Zagonel85, X

Critics claim that focusing on magazine capacity rather than addressing the root causes of gun violence is misguided and ineffective.

Advertisement

Red Flag Laws and Due Process Issues

The proposed national red flag law has been a focal point of criticism. Second Amendment advocates argue that these laws infringe on due process rights by allowing firearms to be seized based on accusations without proper legal procedures.

Advertisement
constitution rights document laid on top of the American flag with a overlay picture of a gun

The 2021 Federal Extreme Risk Protection Order Act, which would enable family members and law enforcement to petition for firearm removal, serves as a precedent for this controversial policy.

Advertisement

The Role of ATF Funding in the DNC Platform

The DNC platform also calls for increased funding for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) to bolster enforcement and prosecution efforts.

Advertisement
Hand of a Person Holding Black Semi Automatic Pistol

Source: Karolina Kaboompics/Pexels

While some support this move to ensure smoother industry functioning, others fear it will be used to crack down on lawful gun owners.

Advertisement

Legal Liability and the PLCAA Debate

A significant point of contention is the DNC’s proposal to strip gun manufacturers of liability protections under the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA).

Advertisement
three machine guns

Source: MathKnight and Zachi Evenor, Wikimedia

Critics argue that this would unfairly penalize manufacturers for crimes committed with their products, shifting blame from criminals to companies.

Advertisement

Second Amendment Foundation's Criticism

The Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) has also voiced strong opposition to the DNC’s platform. Executive Director Adam Kraut described the platform as a “gun-banning wish list” that blames gun ownership rather than criminal behavior for gun violence.

Advertisement
A gun next to a judge’s gavel on top of an American flag.

Source: Bermix Studio/Unsplash

Kraut criticized the focus on banning popular firearms like the AR-15, which is among the most commonly owned rifles in the United States.

Advertisement

The Broader Implications for Gun Rights

Second Amendment advocates warn that the DNC platform’s proposals could set a dangerous precedent for future gun control measures. The potential impact on lawful gun owners, small businesses, and the firearms industry as a whole is a central concern.

Advertisement
A table and wall with many guns, including Remington guns.

Source: Thomas Tucker/Unsplash

As the 2024 election approaches, gun rights groups are rallying their supporters to oppose what they see as an unprecedented assault on constitutional rights.

Advertisement

What’s Next for Gun Rights Advocates?

With the DNC convention underway, gun rights advocates are preparing for a fight. Organizations like GOA and NSSF are ramping up their lobbying efforts and mobilizing their members to defend the Second Amendment.

Advertisement
A person holding and using a gun while at a gun range.

Source: LOGAN WEAVER | @LGNWVR/Unsplash

As the debate over gun control intensifies, the outcome of this battle could have lasting implications for gun rights and public safety in America.

Advertisement