Biden’s $4.5 Billion ‘Racist Highway’ Removal Program Faces Uncertain Future

By: Sam Watanuki | Published: Sep 12, 2024

The Biden-Harris administration has committed $4.5 billion to remove inner-city highways that are seen as remnants of systemic racism. These highways, built in the mid-20th century, often cut through minority neighborhoods, dividing communities and causing lasting economic and social damage.

But as the end of Biden’s term approaches, the future of this ambitious plan remains uncertain.

The President of the United States

Joe Biden officially became President of the United States following his inauguration on January 20, 2021. 

Advertisement
Joe Biden addressing a crowd through a microphone.

Source: Michael Stokes/Wikimedia Commons

The 46th president, alongside his vice-president Kamala Harris and their wider administration, have sought to employ various projects that could help America become a better place for all ethnic groups to live. 

Biden Leaves a Lasting Impact on the US

Democrats believe the Biden Administration has made significant changes to the nation during its tenure as leader, much of which will leave a lasting impact on the US. 

Advertisement
U.S. President Joe Biden (R) talks to Supreme Court Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch and other Justices as he arrives to deliver the State of the Union address during a joint meeting of Congress in the House chamber at the U.S. Capitol.

Source: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images


From the Administration’s overtime guarantee for millions of American workers to their reinvigoration of cleaner energy programs and even reducing the chances of another event such as the Jan. 6 riots, Democrats are pleased with the progress the nation has made under Biden. 

The Highway Removal Program

Over the past three years, the Biden Administration has also proposed various projects aimed at bettering the nation, including its highway initiative. 

Advertisement
Aerial Photo of Buildings and Roads

Source: Aleksejs Bergmanis/Pexels

Alongside Congress, Biden has set aside billions of dollars to rip down sections of highways that run through urban communities in various states throughout the US. 

The Rationale Behind the Initiative

The highway removal effort aims to reconnect communities separated by roadways and heal the scars left by past infrastructure decisions. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a small meeting

Source: Wikimedia

Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg stated in 2021, “There is racism physically built into some of our highways.”

The Removal of Highways

The Biden administration proposes that the highway removal projects would create many jobs for local economies, reduce overall emissions in urban areas, and foster equity in urban development. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a construction site manager

Source: Wikimedia

Most importantly, they would break up divisions between local communities. But, the project appears to have stalled in some states. 

Advertisement

Financial Commitment and Legislative Support

Congress allocated around $4.2 billion for these highway removal projects through two major laws passed in 2021 and 2022. The “Reconnecting Communities” pilot program received $1 billion, and another $3 billion was set aside for “Neighborhood Access and Equity” grants.

Advertisement
Two Person in Long-sleeved Shirt Shakehand

Source: Cytonn Photography/Pexels

These funds were intended to help cities across the U.S. remove highways and reconnect urban neighborhoods.

Advertisement

Early Successes and Challenges in Syracuse and Rochester

In places like Syracuse and Rochester, New York, local officials have worked for years to remove highways dividing their cities.

Advertisement
Light Trails on Highway at Night

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

Rochester’s successful removal of a part of its Inner Loop in 2014 has inspired similar projects, demonstrating both the benefits and challenges of such undertakings.

Advertisement

Biden Administration Sets Aside $180 Million For Syracuse

The Biden administration has also set aside over $180 million for the city of Syracuse, located in Onondaga County, New York. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a construction site

Source: Freepik

This money will eventually go towards helping remove a section of Interstate 81, which currency runs through various neighborhoods. It will also modernize streets, improve local parks, and increase green spaces.

Advertisement

Communities Separated by I-81

U.S. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer’s office explained the construction of I-81 separated communities in Syracuse. 

Advertisement
A photograph of several workmen constructing a new road

Source: Wikimedia

“When I-81 was built, it cut through the heart of Syracuse; it fractured a once vibrant neighborhood and left scars of systemic inequality that are felt to this day,” he said

Advertisement

Federal Government Step In to Fix Problems

Schumer’s office claims the Federal government is doing the right thing by taking accountability for the invasive nature of I-81 and correcting its mistakes. 

Advertisement
The exterior of the domes roof of the US capitol building surrounded by lush greenery

Source: Public Domain/Wikipedia Commons

“Federal policies are what created the concrete walls of I-81 that divided Syracuse neighborhoods, and today, the federal government is stepping up to right that historical wrong,” he said

Advertisement

Slow Progress in Funding Allocation

Despite the ambitious goals, progress has been slow even though the Transportation Department announced that around $3.5 billion in grants associated with the programs are available. 

Advertisement
A photograph of several US bills

Source: Freepik

As of now, only about 4% of the $3.5 billion in announced grants has been fully obligated by the Department of Transportation.

Advertisement

Problems With the Grants

Unlike regular highway funds, which can be easily allocated and put to use as they are distributed by the state, Federal grants are slightly more problematic. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a large meeting

Source: Wikimedia

Many federal grants require local agencies to sign funding agreements with the federal government, a process that has proven time-consuming and complex.

Advertisement

Extended Waits With Federal Grants

Department of Transport spokesperson Sean Manning explained that it’s normal to see longer delays so far as federal grants are concerned. 

Advertisement
The exterior of a large stone building with an American flag.

Source: Kidfly182/Wikipedia Commons

“Every week, we are seeing more and more grant agreements signed, and we expect agreements for many of the most significant projects to be completed by January, including for the project in Syracuse,” he said.

Advertisement

Potential Impact of a Trump Administration

If former President Donald Trump wins a second term, the future of the highway removal initiative could be in jeopardy. A new administration might prioritize different infrastructure projects or change the criteria for awarding grants.

Advertisement
Former U.S. President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally at the Trump National Doral Golf Club on July 09, 2024 in Doral, Florida. Trump continues to campaign across the country

Source: Joe Raedle/Getty Images

Equity, a core principle guiding the current grants, could be removed, shifting the focus away from rebuilding communities of color.

Advertisement

Trump Set to Reform Congressional Spending

Trump has said on several occasions that if he wins a second term as President of the US, he will bring congressional spending under control, which could result in the cancellation of several federal programs. 

Advertisement
A photograph of Donald Trump dancing on stage

Source: Wikimedia

This has left proponents of the highway initiative worried, with some arguing the president should have no say in federal programs. 

Advertisement

Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025

The Controversial Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025, which is associated with Trump yet aims to inspire future conservative leaders, has called for an end to grants such as the freeway removal program. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a large meeting

Source: Freepik

“These policies include a focus on ‘equity,’ a nebulous concept that in practice means awarding grants to favored identity groups,” the plan states.

Advertisement

DOT’s Efforts to Expedite Funding Agreements

In response to the slow pace of progress, the Department of Transportation has been working to expedite the grant process. They are providing technical assistance and expediting paperwork with local sponsors to ensure agreements are signed.

Advertisement
A photograph of several cars passing quickly along a multi-lane road

Source: Freepik

The majority of significant projects are expected to have agreements in place by January 2025.

Advertisement

Kamala Harris and the Highway Removal Push

Vice President Kamala Harris has been a vocal supporter of the highway removal initiative. In April 2024, she visited Atlanta to promote a $185 million grant aimed at building a cap over a downtown freeway.

Advertisement
A photograph of Kamala Harris during a speech

Source: Wikimedia

This project seeks to reconnect a historic African-American neighborhood with the city’s business district, highlighting the administration’s commitment to racial equity in infrastructure.

Advertisement

Local Perspectives

For many in cities like Rochester and Syracuse, the highway removal projects represent an opportunity to correct past injustices. Local activists, such as Shawn Dunwoody of Rochester, emphasize the importance of community input in these projects.

Advertisement
A photograph of several cars in a traffic jam

Source: Wikimedia

“These neighborhoods were destroyed,” Dunwoody said. “Everyone got treated the same—poorly.” The projects aim to restore not just infrastructure but also community trust and cohesion.

Advertisement

Broader Impact of Highway Removal Projects

Removing highways can have broad economic and social benefits. In Rochester, tearing down a section of the Inner Loop created 7 acres of land for new development, adding over $250 million to the city’s tax base.

Advertisement
A photograph of traffic in a city

Source: Wikimedia

These projects offer a chance to increase urban density, reduce reliance on cars, and foster more sustainable city planning.

Advertisement

Mayer Proposes People Should Have a Say

After the success of the first highway removal project in Rochester, the city is attempting to line up another project that would tear down an even larger section of the Inner Loop. 

Advertisement
A photograph of reporters interviewing a man on the street

Source: Freepik

According to Suzanne Mayer, who runs the nonprofit group Hinge Neighbors, the city must listen to the desires of its citizens, adding, “If the city fails to listen to the citizenship, they will have lost the chance, now and in the future.”

Advertisement

Future Challenges and Considerations

While there are significant benefits, the challenges are just as real. Funding delays, political opposition, and administrative hurdles have slowed progress.

Advertisement
A photograph of a construction site

Source: Freepik

Moreover, concerns about gentrification and displacement of existing residents pose potential risks to achieving the intended goals of these projects.

Advertisement

The Uncertain Future of Biden’s Bet

As President Biden’s term winds down, his bold bet on removing “racist highways” faces an uncertain future.

Advertisement
A photograph of Joe Biden on stage

Source: Wikimedia

The slow pace of funding allocation, the possibility of political shifts, and the complexity of urban redevelopment all contribute to a challenging path ahead.

Advertisement