Californians Shocked by Health Insurance Taxes

By: Sam Watanuki | Published: Jun 04, 2024

Many Californians are taken aback each tax season by unexpected bills due to overestimated health insurance subsidies.

In 2021, a staggering 415,000 households collectively owed the IRS close to $690 million, averaging $1,662 per household. These surprises stem from the complex subsidy system of Covered California.

The Role of Covered California

Covered California, the state’s insurance marketplace, offers subsidies to make health insurance more affordable.

Advertisement
Tax return forms with a yellow sticky note on top that says “Tax time!” in black writing.

Source: Nataliya Vaitkevich/Pexels

These subsidies are based on income estimates, which if inaccurately reported, can result in receiving excess aid. This excess is then clawed back by the IRS during tax filing, causing financial strain.

Understanding Subsidy Reconciliation

The process of reclaiming excess subsidies is known as “reconciliation.” It requires individuals to repay any overestimated aid when they file their taxes.

Advertisement
A red arrow on a chart going down.

Source: Freepik/Freepik

This often catches people off guard, especially those in lower-income households who may not have anticipated owing money.

Impact on Lower-Income Families

In 2021, half of the households that owed money to the IRS due to excess premium subsidies earned less than $50,000.

Advertisement
A woman looks over her bills, clearly stressed

Source: Freepik

These repayments can be particularly burdensome for families already managing tight budgets, adding stress during tax season.

Proactive Reporting of Income Changes

Insurance brokers advise that to avoid these unexpected bills, it’s crucial to report any income changes to Covered California promptly.

Advertisement
A person sitting on the floor filling out tax forms. A smartphone is on the floor with the calculator app open.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

This includes bonuses, additional freelance work, or even gambling winnings. Accurate, up-to-date information helps adjust subsidy amounts appropriately.

Common Reporting Mistakes

Many people mistakenly use last year’s income to estimate their current year’s earnings.

Advertisement
Some tax papers next to a notepad and pen.

Source: Olga DeLawrence/Unsplash

Alex Hernandez, an insurance broker, emphasizes the importance of basing estimates on the current financial situation to prevent receiving too much aid.

Advertisement

Year-Round Updates

Covered California encourages enrollees to update their income and household size throughout the year, not just during open enrollment.

Advertisement
A woman working on her laptop with money, papers, and her phone open to the calculator app on the desk beside her.

Source: Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels

Frequent updates can help ensure subsidy amounts are accurate, reducing the likelihood of owing money at tax time.

Advertisement

Unexpected Income Variations

For freelancers and small business owners, predicting future income can be particularly challenging due to its variable nature.

Advertisement
Dozens of US $100 bills are spread out on a surface

Source: Freepik

This unpredictability can lead to significant discrepancies in estimated income and actual earnings, resulting in subsidy overpayments.

Advertisement

Seeking Professional Help

Insurance agents can provide valuable assistance in managing health insurance subsidies.

Advertisement
Empty tax return papers on a table with a pen and a cup of coffee.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

Hernandez suggests enrollees check in with an agent regularly to stay informed and adjust their information as needed. This service is often free, as agents earn commissions from insurance companies.

Advertisement

Balancing Monthly Savings and Annual Costs

Despite potential tax season surprises, many find that the monthly savings on health insurance outweigh the drawbacks. Even if they owe the IRS, the overall cost is often less than what they’d pay for an unsubsidized health plan or unexpected medical expenses.

Advertisement
100 US Dollar Banknotes

Source: John Guccione/Pexels

“We just tell them, ‘Hey, you know what, these things can be unpredictable. You want to have some savings,’” says Audrey Casillas from Koreatown Youth and Community Center.

Advertisement

The Importance of Having Additional Savings

Maintaining some savings to cover unexpected expenses like these tax bills is a great proactive decision. Having a financial cushion can help manage the unpredictability of health insurance subsidies.

Advertisement
Some tax forms and a pen on a table next to a coffee mug.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

For lower-income households, this of course, can be challenging, but if individuals are able to set aside even a small amount each month, it can make a significant difference in the long run.

Advertisement

Looking Forward

As Californians continue to navigate the complexities of health insurance subsidies, staying proactive and informed can help mitigate the shock of unexpected tax bills.

Advertisement
A man is pictured looking into his wallet to find it empty

Source: Freepik

Regular updates and professional guidance are key to ensuring subsidy amounts accurately reflect current financial situations.

Advertisement