Christian Group Call For Resignation of Prominent Supreme Court Justice

By: Ben Campbell | Published: Jul 04, 2024

Faithful America, a group of 180,000 Christians, has started a petition demanding US Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito to resign.

The move comes after leaked recordings revealed Alito’s controversial comments about God’s role in U.S. society. The petition signifies a major shift in the support from a traditionally conservative base.

Faithful America’s Mission

Faithful America is dedicated to social justice, defending the separation of church and state, and opposing Christian nationalism. The group’s petition against Alito highlights their commitment to these values.

Advertisement
A photograph taken inside a church

Source: Freepik

Newsweek describes the organization as a prominent advocate for these causes, aiming to hold influential figures accountable.

Leaked Comments Spark Outrage

In leaked recordings, Alito discusses the ideological divide in the U.S., stating, “One side or the other is going to win.”

Advertisement
A woman is pictured alongside a group of protesters on the street

Source: Freepik

He admits the differences between the left and right are impossible to reconcile. These comments have raised concerns about his impartiality as a Supreme Court Justice.

Alito’s Call for “Godliness”

The most alarming part of the recordings for many was Alito’s call to restore “godliness” in the U.S.

Advertisement
Sources Other Than the Bible That Mention Jesus by Name

Source: Pixabay

He agreed that it’s important to keep fighting for a return to these values. This stance has intensified the debate over his ability to separate personal beliefs from his judicial duties.

Filmmaker Secretly Records Alito

Alito made the controversial comments during a dinner party. According to reports, filmmaker Lauren Windsor secretly recorded the voice clip. 

Advertisement
A reporter is pictured taking notes

Source: Freepik

These comments have left many questioning whether Alito’s personal opinions may affect his ability to perform his judicial duties fairly.

Alito Faces Further Scrutiny

Alito faced further scrutiny after another comment uttered by the justice appeared online.

Advertisement
A photograph of US Justice Samuel Alito

Source: Getty Images

“One side or the other is going to win. I mean, there can be a way of working, a way of living together peacefully, but it’s difficult because there are differences in fundamental things that can’t be compromised. So it’s not like you are going to split the difference,” he said.

Advertisement

Past Controversies Resurface

This isn’t Alito’s first brush with controversy, though. In 2021, an upside-down U.S. flag was seen flying over his home in Alexandria, Virginia.

Advertisement
Inverted American flag on wooden surface

Source: Freepik

This flag, often used by Trump supporters to signify dissent post-2020 election, raised eyebrows and questions about his political leanings.

Advertisement

Responsibility for the Flag

The Washington Post reported that Martha-Ann Alito, his wife, took responsibility for the controversial flag, calling it a “signal of distress.”

Advertisement
A photograph of Supreme Court Justice Alito at the White House

Source: Wikimedia

She allegedly spat out at neighbors, which added fuel to the already burning fire of public scrutiny. This incident added to the perception of Alito’s household’s political stance.

Advertisement

Alito Explains the Upside-Down Flag

Alito would later comment on the upside-down flag that appeared outside his home in Virginia. 

Advertisement
The US flag on a flagpole waving in the sky.

Source: Chris Robert/Unsplash

“My wife is a private citizen, and she possesses the same First Amendment rights as every other American,” Alito wrote a letter sent to members of Congress. “She makes her own decisions, and I have always respected her right to do so,” he said

Advertisement

Justice Claims He Was Unaware of the Connection

Alito claims he was unaware of the connection between the upside-down American flag and the so-called “Stop the Steal” movement. 

Advertisement
A photograph of several people involved in the Stop the Steal movement

Source: Wikimedia

“I was not aware of any connection between that historic flag and the ‘Stop the Steal Movement,’ and neither was my wife. She did not fly it to associate herself with that or any other group, and the use of an old historic flag by a new group does not necessarily drain that flag of all other meanings,” he said

Advertisement

The “Appeal to Heaven” Flag

In 2023, the Alitos had the “Appeal to Heaven” flag displayed at their vacation home in New Jersey.

Advertisement
Girl praising the heavens

Source: unknown

This revolutionary-era banner is often used by far-right movements to highlight Christian values, further complicating Alito’s image as an impartial judge.

Advertisement

Faithful America’s Stand

Faithful America’s petition (which has gained more than enough signatures to pass its goal) is a clear statement against what they perceive as Alito’s inability to separate his faith from his judicial responsibilities.

Advertisement
A photograph of a man singing a petition

Source: Freepik

Their stand reflects a broader concern among Christians about maintaining the integrity of the judiciary and upholding the separation of church and state.

Advertisement

Public Reaction

The public reaction to Alito’s comments and the subsequent petition has been mixed. Some see it as a necessary step to preserve judicial impartiality, while others view it as an attack on a conservative ally.

Advertisement
A photograph of a reporter on the street

Source: Freepik

The leaked recordings and past controversies continue to spark debate.

Advertisement

A Call For Alito to Resign

Following the controversial actions of Alito, the Christian group Faithful America took it upon themselves to call for Alito’s resignation and went as far as to start a petition to achieve their goal. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a large group of people protesting on the street

Source: Wikimedia

The petition reads: “Dear Justice Samuel Alito, As members of the Christian organization Faithful America, we are deeply disappointed by your recent comments at the Supreme Court Historical Society’s annual dinner, agreeing that the United States should move to a place of ‘godliness.”

Advertisement

Alito's Comments Violate Separation of Church and State

According to Faithful America, Alito’s comments clearly violate the separation of the Church and state. 

Advertisement
A photograph taken inside a church

Source: Freepik

“These comments distort Christianity, violate the separation of church and state, and appear to endorse an extra-judicial agenda of Christian nationalism,” reads the petition. 

Advertisement

Unfit to Serve as Supreme Court Justice

As a result of his alleged nationalist beliefs, the Christian organization has deemed Alito unfit to serve as a Supreme Court Justice.

Advertisement
The Supreme Court justices seen together in a group portrait in 2022.

Source: Public Domain/Wikimedia Commons

“One of the flags, the ‘Appeal to Heaven,’ is even a symbol of Christian nationalism carried by insurrectionists. You are unfit to serve on our nation’s highest court, and we demand that you immediately resign. Thank you,” they wrote

Advertisement

Petition Gains Traction

The Faithless America petition has garnered significant support online, obtaining over 17,000 signatures by mid-June. 

Advertisement
A photograph of a man singing a petition

Source: Freepik

While the Christian group, which defines itself as a “community of Christians putting faith into action for love and social justice,” initially set a goal of 15,000 signatures, once this was achieved, they promptly raised the target to 20,000. 

Advertisement

The Importance of Judicial Impartiality

The role of a Supreme Court Justice requires an unwavering commitment to impartiality. Alito’s comments and the symbols displayed at his homes have raised serious questions about his ability to remain unbiased.

Advertisement
Supreme Court

Source: Kjetil Ree, Wikimedia

This issue shows the importance of maintaining a clear division between personal beliefs and judicial duties.

Advertisement

Updated Comments From Faithful America

The Christian group added further comments to its petition site, alleging that Alito’s comments violate the Constitution and that he should be held accountable for them. 

Advertisement
A photograph of the US Constitution

Source: Wikimedia

“(Alito’s) extraordinary comments twist our faith, endorse a Christian-nationalist agenda, and violate the Constitutional separation of church and state — and that’s not all. They also come on the heels of the news that Alito’s homes flew two right-wing flags contesting the legitimacy of the 2020 election,” they wrote.

Advertisement

The Future of Faithful America’s Petition

The petition against Alito is gaining traction, but its success remains uncertain. Regardless of the outcome, Faithful America’s actions have highlighted significant concerns about the intersection of faith and judicial responsibility.

Advertisement
Lawyer fills out paperwork on a desk with a judges gavel beside him

Source: Freepik

Their effort represents a growing national demand for accountability and transparency.

Advertisement

A Turning Point

The petition by Faithful America marks a significant moment in the relationship between Christians and conservative allies in the Supreme Court.

Advertisement
Two men holding each other by the shoulders and lifting their hands

Source: Sam Balye/Unsplash

It reflects a broader shift in priorities and a demand for judges who can uphold their duties without letting personal beliefs interfere. This movement could signal future challenges for other justices with similar backgrounds.

Advertisement

Faithful America Call For More Signatures

Faithful America has called on like-minded people across the states to come forward and sign the petition, which could ultimately force the controversial justice to step down. 

Advertisement
A man is pictured signing a document

Source: Freepik

“This man is far from impartial and cannot remain a justice on our nation’s highest court. As a grassroots movement of Christians, let’s join together to demand that Justice Alito immediately resign,” they wrote

Advertisement

Alito Won’t Step Down Willingly

Alito has since come out and confirmed he has no plans to willingly step down. 

Advertisement
A photograph of US Justice Samuel Alito

Source: Getty Images

“I am confident that a reasonable person who is not motivated by political or ideological considerations or a desire to affect the outcome of Supreme Court cases would conclude that the events … do not meet the applicable standard for recusal,” he wrote. “I am, therefore, required to reject your request,” said Alito.

Advertisement

The High Standards of Supreme Court Justices

Despite his attempt to convince the American people that his comments have no significant outcome on his ability to uphold the law, Faithful Americans believe otherwise. 

Advertisement
The U.S. Supreme Court building.

Pacamah/Wikimedia Commons

They argue that Alito’s comments raise certain ethical concerns and that the Justice’s recent actions have fallen short of the high standards expected of Supreme Court Justices. 

Advertisement