Einstein’s “Greatest Mistake” May Actually Help Explain Why The Universe is Expanding So Quickly

By: May Man Published: Jun 27, 2024

What comprises the universe? This question has captivated astronomers for centuries. For the last 25 years, scientists have understood that “normal” matter, such as atoms and molecules that make up everything we see, including ourselves and Earth, constitutes only 5 percent of the universe.

Another 25 percent consists of “dark matter,” an elusive substance that, while invisible, exerts gravitational effects on normal matter.

Dark Energy Driving Expansion

The remaining 70 percent of the universe is made up of “dark energy.”

Advertisement
A photograph of a large galaxy in the universe

Source: Wikimedia

Discovered in 1998, dark energy is believed to be driving the universe’s accelerated expansion.

Complexity of Dark Energy

A new study, soon to be published in the Astronomical Journal, has provided the most detailed measurements of dark energy to date.

Advertisement
An artist's depiction of outer space

Source: Wikimedia

The findings suggest it might be a hypothetical vacuum energy first proposed by Einstein, or it could be something more complex that varies over time.

Einstein’s “Greatest Mistake”

Over a century ago, when Einstein formulated the General Theory of Relativity, he realized his equations implied the universe should be expanding or contracting.

Advertisement
A black and white photograph of the German physicist Albert Einstein

Source: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

To counteract this and maintain a static universe, he introduced a “cosmological constant”—an inherent energy in empty space. However, when Henrietta Swan Leavitt and Edwin Hubble demonstrated that the universe was indeed expanding, Einstein discarded the cosmological constant, labeling it his “greatest mistake.”

Discovery from the 90’s

In 1998, two research teams discovered that the universe’s expansion was accelerating, indicating the possible existence of something akin to Einstein’s cosmological constant—now known as dark energy.

Advertisement
A view of earth from space.

Source: Earth Science and Remote Sensing Unit/Wikimedia

Since then, supernovae and other methods have been used to study dark energy’s nature.

Dark Energy Remains Constant

These observations have suggested that the density of dark energy remains constant, even as the universe expands

Advertisement
Einstein next to blackboard

Source: Wikimedia

This constancy is measured by a parameter called w. Einstein’s cosmological constant effectively set w at –1, and previous observations have supported this value.

Advertisement

Utilizing Brightness

To measure the universe’s contents and its growth rate, astronomers use “standard candles”—objects with known brightness.

Advertisement
An image of space which shows a giant planet below a bright star

Source: Freepik

By comparing their apparent brightness, distances can be calculated.

Advertisement

Measuring Exploding Stars

Type Ia supernovae, a type of exploding star, serve as a common cosmic light bulb. These explosions occur when white dwarf stars accumulate enough mass from a companion star to reach 1.44 times the mass of the Sun, leading to an explosion.

Advertisement
exploding star in space

Source: Freepik

By measuring the rate at which these explosions fade, astronomers can determine their brightness and distance.

Advertisement

No Small Project

The Dark Energy Survey, the largest project of its kind, involves over 400 scientists from multiple continents.

Advertisement
The Dark Energy Survey group

Source: Wikimedia

Over nearly a decade, they have repeatedly observed sections of the southern sky, looking for new supernovae.

Advertisement

Higher Precision in Research

Frequent observations and a wide search area increase the number of supernovae detected.

Advertisement
A bright explosive-like light with a glowing blue orb hovering in space to the top left of it.

Source: NOIRLab, M. Zamani/Wikimedia Commons

Initial dark energy measurements used only a few dozen supernovae. The latest Dark Energy Survey results utilize about 1,500 supernovae, providing much greater precision.

Advertisement

Technological Advancements

Using a specially designed camera on the 4-meter Blanco Telescope in Chile, the survey identified thousands of supernovae.

Advertisement
Blanco Telescope against blue sky and clouds

Source: Wikimedia

The 4-meter Anglo-Australian Telescope in New South Wales helped classify these supernovae by analyzing their light spectra, revealing unique features like the absence of hydrogen and silicon in Type Ia supernovae. Machine learning further facilitated the efficient classification of thousands of supernovae.

Advertisement

In Another Lifetime

After over a decade of research and the study of around 1,500 Type Ia supernovae, the Dark Energy Survey has produced a new measurement of w, finding it to be –0.80 ± 0.18, which ranges between –0.62 and –0.98.

Advertisement
An artist's rendition of an event in space

Source: Wikimedia

This intriguing result is close to –1 but not exact, suggesting that dark energy might be more complex than previously thought and could vary over the universe’s lifetime.

Advertisement