Newsom Deals New Blow to Oakland’s Woke Prosecutor

By: Alyssa Miller | Last updated: Aug 23, 2024

A huge announcement was made on Monday, just months after the California Highway Patrol expanded its work to Oakland in an effort to assist with the overwhelming crime rates. Alameda County’s district attorney, Pamela Price, was in charge of overseeing the changes.

Now, California Governor Gavin Newsom has notified the woke prosecutor that the National Guard prosecutors will be brought in to complete the task. This will be a huge blow to Price’s career as a left-leaning attorney.

What Is Going on With Crime in Oakland?

Since 2011, Oakland has been the victim of a widespread progressive movement, shifting the city from a family-friendly locale to a city with rising costs, budgeting issues, and rising crime.

Advertisement
A wall with graffiti that reads to "defund the police"

Source: Levi Meir Clancy/Unsplash

Since then, residents have become increasingly frustrated with local and state leadership. Now, crime and gang activity has become more than a nuisance, driving out good-meaning families and encouraging more carjacking and robberies every day.

New Law Enforcement Being Brought In

After Newsome made the announcement on Monday, he noted that the National Guard’s Counterdrug Task Force had finally reached an agreement with the California Department of Justice.

Advertisement
A man wearing army fatigues with a face mask, helmet, gloves, and sunglasses standing at the top of a set of stairs

Source: Chris Henry/Unsplash

The Democrat Governor hopes the group can be ‘modeled after a successful partnership established in San Francisco with District Attorney Brooke Jenkins, which has helped boost felony narcotics convictions in San Francisco.’

Finalized Agreement

During his speech to the residents of Oakland, Newsome remarked, ‘I am grateful for the quick work here by the Attorney General and the California National Guard to swiftly finalize this agreement so these talented attorneys can soon help secure justice for the people of the Bay Area.’

Advertisement
Gavin Newsom speaking into a microphone pointing his finger out to the crowd

Source: @QuoteDigging/X

Last year, a rash of day light robberies and thousands of daily car break-ins made the residents of California call on the Governor for added help in the city.

Price Is Removed From the Task Force

Newsom stated that Price’s office was not included in the deal because it missed the application deadline.

Advertisement
A woman with curly black hair stands at a set of microphones delivering a speech in front of an Alameda County sign

Source: @dannoyes/X

However, her team was previously in charge of lowering crime rates in the Bay Area without success.

Cracking Down on Crime in Oakland

Earlier this year, Gavin Newsom deployed hundreds of California Highway Patrol officers to the streets of Oakland in the hopes of cracking down on criminal activity.

Advertisement
A crime scene on a street with several police cars and yellow caution tape

Source: @SenecaSpeaks21/X

The city, with just over 400,000 residents across the bay from San Francisco, faces some of the highest crime rates in the country. In the idyllic coastline of California, some have a hard time understanding how the situation got so bad.

Advertisement

Price Responded To the Changes

Price issued a statement following the governor’s remarks about the changes being made in California.

Advertisement
A woman with curly black hair wears a purple blouse while conducting an interview

Source: @YayAreaNews/X

She said, ‘We hope the swift agreement reached between the DOJ and CalGuard yields equally swift results, and my office is willing to assist in that effort in any way possible.’

Advertisement

Unhelpful Campaigns To End Crime

Many of Price’s critics point out the fact that the district attorney ran on a platform of offender rehabilitation and police accountability as a method of reducing the crime rate in the Bay area.

Advertisement
a car with a recently burned interior

Source: Casey Keyler/Unsplash

Regardless of the changes, San Francisco and the Bay Area have seen a large spike in violent crimes, including various drug-related offenses, retail theft, and auto burglaries.

Advertisement

The Prosecutor Is Now Facing a Recall Election

Due to the ineffectual nature of her office, Price is now facing a recall just two years after being elected in November 2022.

Advertisement
A glass door with several signs for a polling station on it

Source: Elliot Stallion/Unsplash

Chesa Boudin was ousted from the top prosecutor’s job just a few months ago. Boudin was another political freshman, and in his first year as a district attorney, he proved to be unpopular with voters and residents in the area.

Advertisement

Price's History in the State

Before moving into the elected office, Price worked as a civil rights attorney. She was known as a champion for women’s rights, victims of domestic violence, and youth caught up in the predatory criminal justice system.

Advertisement
A man dressed in an orange jumpsuit sits alone in a prison cell

Source: Freepik

Although she is an outspoken advocate for victim’s rights, she also has a soft stance on violent crime and repeat offenders. She has often decried the current prison system and claims that more help could be done with a restitution system instead of a punitive one.

Advertisement

Criticism of Her Role

Her major opponents have said that this method of dealing with criminals only emboldens them to participate in accelerating crimes.

Advertisement
A close-up of red, white, and blue lights on a police car.

Source: Scott Rodgerson/Unsplash

They also say that her role as a soft-on-crime District Attorney began when violent crime was rising in the state and needed a heavy-handed approach to quelch the dissonance. In response to these criticisms, Gov. Gavin Newsome was forced to send in highway patrol officers and state prosecutors to help Price accomplish some of the goals of the office.

Advertisement

Her Supporters Say Otherwise

Price has plenty of support in the left-leaning district of Oakland. They say that she has been targeted by wealthy conservatives who do want the justice system to be reformed in the state.

Advertisement
A large room of people waiting for a recall election meeting in Berkeley, CA

Source: @BerkeleyScanner/X

Currently, the cash-for-bail and for-profit prison system brings in billions in revenue each year. Price’s system of having a more community-based rehabilitation system would cost the country money instead of funding over-stuffed corporate profits.

Advertisement

Newsom’s Accusations

Tension between Newsom and Price has been growing for some time. In July, a letter accused Price of effectively refusing the state’s help to prosecute drug crimes in Oakland. In response, Newsome rescinded an offer to dispatch attorneys to assist the city.

Advertisement
Gavin Newsom speaking into a microphone pointing his finger out to the crowd

Source: @QuoteDigging/X

“Despite our outreach, your office has yet to make use of these resources,” Newsom’s Cabinet Secretary Ann Patterson wrote in a letter to Price’s office, (via Politico).

Advertisement

Pushing Back

In a press conference the next day, Price pushed back against this accusation, stating that Newsom was “misinformed” about her office’s staffing and asserting that she had made efforts to accept the governor’s offer.

Advertisement
Pamela Price speaking at a podium

Source: Pamela Price, Alameda County District Attorney - Personal/Facebook

“There were multiple meetings and discussions, and we thought we were in fact addressing the terms and conditions” of the partnership, she said, adding she was “disappointed that the governor did not reach out to me directly.”

Advertisement

A Blow to Price

The reversal is another blow to Price as she fights a recall election. Newsom’s intervention also opens an unusually public rift between a publicly elected prosecutor and state governor.

Advertisement
A 'Vote' sign is posted at the Orange County Registrar of Voters less than two weeks before midterms Election Day on October 27, 2022 in Santa Ana, California

Source: Mario Tama/Getty Images

Crime has become one of the biggest, most volatile, and divisive issues for California Democrats, with many of the state’s politicians unable and unwilling to see eye-to-eye on the real issue at hand.

Advertisement

A Strain on Politicians 

Public safety has caused strain on Oakland’s politicians, with Price and the city’s Mayor Sheng Thao facing recall votes in November, as crime rates create whiplash for residents. In 2023, the crime rates in the city reached new highs, prompting Newsom and state Attorney General Rob Bonta to intervene.

Advertisement
Sheng Thao speaks onstage at the TAAF Heritage Month Summit

Source: The Asian American Foundation

However, a new report showed that Oakland’s crime rate has been steadily falling in 2024.

Advertisement

Crime Rates Improved in the City

Police statistics showed that Oakland’s public safety was improving significantly earlier this year. Despite recent media reports that cast doubt, the data shows that crime is down by 33% when compared to the same period last year.

Advertisement
A wall with graffiti that reads to "defund the police"

Source: Levi Meir Clancy/Unsplash

City Hall attributes the improvement to changes in the operation and organization of the city’s police department (via, the SF Chronicle).

Advertisement

The Cause of the Crime Uptick

At the beginning of 2023, City Hall officials conducted an audit funded by Kaiser Permanente and the Department of Justice and carried out by the nonprofit California Partnership of Safe Communities after homicide numbers in Oakland failed to decrease compared to other cities in the Golden State.

Advertisement
An NYPD car on the side of the road with red lights flashing.

Source: @CrimeInNYC/X

The audit found that the city had walked away from its Ceasefire crime-reduction program from 2016 to 2020.

Advertisement

What Is the Ceasefire Program? 

Ceasefire is a violence interruption strategy that identifies individuals most likely to become perpetrators or victims of violent crime and connects them with experienced police officers, mentors, and community members to prevent violence before it occurs.

Advertisement
Close-up of tattooed hands gripping the bars of a jail cell, with an orange prison uniform visible in the background

Source: RDNE Stock Project/Pexels

According to the city, the program resulted in a 42% reduction in homicides from 2012 to 2017.

Advertisement

A Huge Pay Off

“Oakland is turning the corner and the public safety investments we have made are paying off,” Mayor Thao said in a statement.

Advertisement
An image of downtown Oakland on a blue day

Source: Ethan Oringel/Flickr

“Our hard fought progress is fueled by strengthening our police department, reviving the proven violence prevention initiative Ceasefire, collaborating with the state and federal government, and partnering with Oakland based businesses.”

Advertisement

More Work Ahead

David Muhammad, executive director of the Oakland-based National Institute for Criminal Justice Reform, said the city has a lot of work ahead to get back to the low numbers of the pre-pandemic era.

Advertisement
homeless man laying on side street with dirty clothes

Source: Jcomp, Freepik

“There’s some normal reduction because things had gotten pretty high and pretty bad—what some would call regression to the mean,” he said. “But in reality, things are trending in the right direction, and I’m incredibly encouraged by it.”

Advertisement

An Uptick in Recent Crime

But recent incidents in the city by the bay have painted a different picture in the last month. A spike in carjackings and a recent shooting at a popular lake have changed the perspective on the decline in crime.

Advertisement
Two NYPD police cars side by side.

Source: Alexi Rosenfeld/Getty Images

Newsom is also fed up with the city’s crime and the officials who are seemingly uncooperative with his plans.

Advertisement

Price’s POV on Crime

Like Boudin, Price upset the political establishment when she won office with a vow to reduce sentencing and prosecute more police officers.

Advertisement
A photograph of a Police Officer at a Protest in NYC

Source: Wikimedia

Her election came off the heels of the Black Lives Matter movement that re-sparked in 2020 after George Floyd was a victim of police brutality by a Minnesota police officer.

Advertisement

The Price of a Recall

Another similarity Price shares with her predecessor is that she is confronting a recall campaign funded by deep-pocketed interest groups, which include real estate firms.

Advertisement
A person wearing a blue mask leaning over a table voting on a ballot

Source: Phil Roeder/Flickr

Price has criticized the recall as an anti-democratic project of “a handful of wealthy folks” seeking to overturn her election for someone who more closely resembles the wants of the elites and businesses in the city.

Advertisement