Decades-Old Fish Removal from a Colorado Pond Uncovers Nationwide Fishing Hotspot Problem

By: Alyssa Miller | Last updated: Jun 17, 2024

Imagine catching one of the largest fish of your entire life. Well, for those of you fishing in an Arvada park, your chances of catching that big fish are a lot smaller now.

Last week, Colorado Parks and Wildlife officials removed 14 massive, invasive carp from a pond at an Arvada park after introducing the fish as part of a national study.

Bighead Carp Were Discovered

After 30 years, state officials were tipped off to the presence of a bighead carp at Jack B. Tomlinson Park by an angler.

Advertisement
A person fishi

Source: Lum3n/Pexels

While the impacts of the bighead carp are unknown at this time, they are an invasive species that rely on plankton for food, which could lead to reductions in populations.

An Angler Spotted the Fish

“This operation all started with a tip from an angler,” said Philip Sorensen, CPW District Wildlife Manager for Westminster and Arvada in a statement.

Advertisement
CPW aquatic staff holding a large carp

Source: Colorado Parks and Wildlife/Colorado Parks and Wildlife/TNS

“We are grateful when the public reaches out to tell us about invasive species in their neighborhoods. We want to know about the presence of invasive species.”

The Carp Were Removed

Agency officials stated in a news release that they removed the fish after stunning them with an electric current in the water.

Advertisement
A man holding a bighead carp near a lake

Source: U.S. Geological Survey/Flickr

Officials said (via Tribune News Service) that the 14 carp appeared to be leftovers from a 1992 study to see whether the fish could reduce nuisance algae.

The Carp Were Unusually Large

The CPW spokesperson Kara Van Hoose said in an email to the Tribune News Service that it is unusual for bighead carp to live that long in the water.

Advertisement
A grass crap swimming in a lake

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The carp, which are part of the Asian carp family, typically live for about 16 years, but they can live longer, according to the US Fish and Wildlife Service.

The 14 Fish Were Massive

Each of the 14 fish caught in the pond measured at an average of three feet. The largest of the fish weighed 46 pounds.

Advertisement
CPW aquatic staff remove invasive species from Arvada pond.

Source: Colorado Parks and Wildlife/Colorado Parks and Wildlife/TNS

CPW found the massive carp by using electrofishing methods, which emit electricity into the water, stunning fish into a temporary stupor.

Advertisement

The Threat of Carp

As mentioned earlier, bighead carp are not native to Colorado. These fish can negatively impact the ecosystem as they compete with other fish for plankton.

Advertisement
School of small silver fish swimming in a river

Source: Freepik

The size of the fish indicates that these individuals, which did not reproduce, are the leftover carp from the 1992 study, which ended in 1995.

Advertisement

The Removal of the Carp Never Happened

When the study ended in 1995, the carp were supposed to be removed. However, it seems that the carp stuck around.

Advertisement
Close-up Photo of Survey Spreadsheet

Source: Lukas/Pexels

“The size of the bighead carp removed indicates natural reproduction has most likely not taken place, which was the best case scenario,” said Kyle Battige, senior aquatic biologist for the northeast region of CPW, in a statement.

Advertisement

Other Fish Were Outcompeting the Fish

“Bighead carp are filter feeders and can grow to incredible sizes in both small and large bodies of water,” said CPW Invasive Species Program Manager Robert Walters in a statement.

Advertisement
A boat in the middle of a still lake

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

Walters continued: “Once established, these fish can outcompete native Colorado species for food and resources.”

Advertisement

The Carp Jokes Started Rolling In

CPW joked in a social media post that the discovery of the large abdominal fish prompted many “Jaws” jokes.

Advertisement
Digital illustration of a large prehistoric shark swimming in deep blue ocean waters. The shark has a pale, spotted belly, a dorsal fin, and sharp teeth visible in its open mouth

Source: Benji Paynose/NPS

“Jaws” follows a group of anglers who are on the hunt for an abnormally large, man-eating shark that could bring more harm to the beach town as summer approaches.

Advertisement

CPW Is Grateful to the Tip

“This operation all started with a tip from an angler,” CPW District Wildlife Manager for Westminster and Arvada Philip Sorensen said in a press release.

Advertisement
Boy Holding Fishing Rod

Source: Nubia Navarro (nubikini)/Pexels

Sorensen continued: “We are grateful when the public reaches out to tell us about invasive species in their neighborhoods. We want to know about the presence of invasive species.”

Advertisement

CPW Encourages Reporting Strange Things

Anglers should report anything strange they see while fishing to CPW,” Van Hoose advised.

Advertisement
A lake surrounded by trees in an American park

Source: Visit Arvada

Van Hoose continued: “This is a good example of what can happen to fish which don’t have any natural predators in the area and an endless supply of food.”

Advertisement

Another Invasive Species in US Waters

Arvada Park has removed this invasive species of carp, but another US state faces a threat from a different invasive species of carp.

Advertisement
Asian carp swimming underwater

Source: Kate Gardiner/Flickr

Invasive carp, formerly known as Asian carp, threaten South Dakota’s lakes and rivers by limiting the food supply for native fish inhabiting the waters.

Advertisement

America’s Most Unwanted Fish

South Dakota State University is attempting to limit the number of invasive fish by working with South Dakota Game, Fish, and Parks officials so that natural resources remain largely free from one of America’s most unwanted fish.

Advertisement
Boy Holding Fishing Rod

Source: Nubia Navarro (nubikini)/Pexels

But how did this invasive species of carp become such a problem in the first place? It is due to a mixture of flooding and commercial stock ponds.

Advertisement

How These Invasive Carp Appeared in the US

During the 1970s, people brought fish native to Eastern Asia to the US to help clean commercial stock ponds, aquaculture ponds, and wastewater ponds.

Advertisement
A steamboat seen on the Mississippi River in the daytime.

Source: Tomas Martinez/Unsplash

Eventually, floods allowed these fish to escape into nearby rivers and ponds. By the 2000s, the Mississippi River basin, the Missouri River basin, and the Ohio and Illinois rivers all had established invasive carp populations mixed in with their native carp populations.

Advertisement

How the Invasive Species Work

While bighead and silver carp are the most common and abundant types of invasive carp in the US, both species compete directly with native fish but not with each other.

Advertisement
Asian carp swimming underwater in a tank

Source: Kate Gardiner/Flickr

Established bighead and silver carp populations can quickly consume a majority of plankton, which squeezes out native fish populations.

Advertisement

The Threat to Native Fish Populations

“What we see from other places is that first, you see changes in your plankton and zooplankton, which overall can mean less food for your native species,” Alison Coulter, an assistant professor in SDSU’s Department of Natural Resource Management, tells SD State News.

Advertisement
American white pelicans loaf near shore, Hecla-Grindstone Provincial Park

Source: Shahnoor Habib Munmun

“You will then have poorer feeding conditions for the native fish and eventually that will affect the native fish populations.”

Advertisement

No Natural Predators

Once the invasive species have dominated their territory by gobbling up all of the food, these fish can grow quickly. After a while, they become too big to have any natural predators.

Advertisement
A man holding a silver carp in a boat

Source: D. O'Keefe, Michigan Sea Grant/Wikimedia Commons

Coupled with their ability to breed quickly, these carp can wreak ecological havoc on waterways once they become established.

Advertisement

Increasing Floods Cause a Problem

In South Dakota, increased flooding over the last two decades has plagued most waters with invasive carp. Some fishers have reported that silver carp, known as “flying carp,” jump into their boats, making it a significant problem.

Advertisement
An Asian carp jumping into a boat

Source: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Headquarters/Flickr

“They’re not a problem anywhere else in the state yet, but if people don’t know about them and what they can do, they could become a growing problem,” Coulter said.

Advertisement

Removing These Carp

However, the carp need to be removed soon before they become a problem. When invasive carp become entrenched in a waterway, they are nearly impossible to fully remove.

Advertisement
2 People On The Boat

Source: Quang Nguyen Vinh/Pexels

This is why Coulter and her team are working to create preventative measures to halt carp invasions.

Advertisement

The Billion Dollar Threat

In Chicago, officials are spending billions of dollars on special barriers to prevent invasive carp from entering the Great Lakes.

Advertisement
A close-up of a few hundred dollar bills on a table.

Source: engin akyurt/Unsplash

Officials are eager to implement this preventative measure because they fear the carp could cause more than $7 billion in damage to the commercial fishing industry and $10 billion to the tourism industry if they become entrenched in the Great Lakes.

Advertisement

Another Way These Fish Are Moving

These fish move from one body of water to another by swimming through floodwaters or open waterways, or by humans physically moving them.

Advertisement
Scenic View Of Lake During Sunset

Source: Nicole Avagliano/Pexels

Coulter and her team have created projects to address both challenges.

Advertisement

Refreshing Anglers’ Skills

“Anglers should have a good understanding of what the regulations are,” Coulter said.

Advertisement
A person casting a line into the water

Source: Kathryn Archibald/Pexels

“For example, in South Dakota, you are not supposed to catch live bait for yourself at one waterbody and move it somewhere else. Nor are you allowed to release live bait.”

Advertisement

How You Can Help Remove Invasive Carps

Some preventative measures could include refreshing anglers’ knowledge of state fishing laws, best practices for disposing of live bait, and fish identification.

Advertisement
Woman and Boy Sitting on Dock Holding Fishing Rod

Source: Oleksandr P/Pexels

Many people catch invasive carp but often do not eat them because they mistakenly identify them as common carp, which are considered to have very poor taste. Coulter believes that anglers would keep the invasive carp, which taste similar to tilapia if they knew what was on the other end of their line.

Advertisement