You Could Pay A Lot More in Taxes Under Project 2025

By: Alyssa Miller | Last updated: Aug 14, 2024

Project 2025 is a detailed plan crafted by the conservative Heritage Foundation to guide the next Republican president. The blueprint outlines extensive changes to the federal government, focusing heavily on tax reforms.

Spearheaded by former Trump administration officials, this ambitious plan aims to simplify the tax code and shift economic policies.

What Is Project 2025?

For those unfamiliar with Project 2025, it is a controversial playbook and policy agenda created by a conservative think-tank that ushers in a sweeping overhaul of the executive branch.

Advertisement
Digital illustration of the Republican elephant

Source: Unsplash

CBS News reports that the project comprises four pillars: “a policy guide for the next presidential administration; a LinkedIn-style database of personnel who could serve in the next administration; training for that pool of candidates dubbed the ‘Presidential Administration Academy;’ and a playbook of actions to be taken within the first 180 days in office.”

The Tax Proposals

Project 2025 proposes to eliminate the nation’s long-standing system of multiple tax brackets, which helps lower-income Americans pay a smaller share of their income in federal taxes compared to higher earners.

Advertisement
Mission Economic Development Agency worker Cynthia Valencia helps a client with with free tax preparations on January 27, 2012 in San Francisco, California. The Mission Economic Development Agency is one of 200 Bay Area locations to kick off the Earn it! Keep it! Save it! program that offers free tax preapration services to households that earned less than $50,000 in 2011

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Currently, several tax brackets are based on income thresholds. Project 2025 argues that the current tax system is overly complicated and expensive.

Simplifying the Tax Code

One of the central proposals of Project 2025 is to replace the current seven tax brackets with just two. This change aims to simplify the tax filing process for Americans.

Advertisement
A calculator, a pen, glasses, and a post-in that reads “Tax Time” on top of several US tax forms

Source: Freepik

Under the new system, those earning up to $168,000 would pay a 15% tax rate, while those earning above that would face a 30% tax rate.

The Proposed Plan

The plan wants to solve the complex and expensive problem by proposing just two tax rates.

Advertisement
A photograph of a female researcher working at her desk

Source: Freepik

It also proposes eliminating “most deductions, credits, and exclusions,” but the blueprint doesn’t specify which ones would go and which would stay.

Creating a Progressive Tax System

“The federal income tax system is progressive, and people who make more money pay a higher marginal tax rate than people who make less money,” Brendan Duke, senior director for economic policy at the left-leaning Center for American Progress, told CBS MoneyWatch.

Advertisement
A man is pictured looking into his wallet to find it empty

Source: Freepik

“Conservatives look at that, and they feel that it’s unfair to the wealthy to ask them to pay a greater share of their income in taxes than lower-income families.”

Advertisement

Reforming Taxes With a Catch

The Project 2025 proposal “is a dramatic reform of how we fund our government, where we ask the wealthy to pitch in more than lower-income families,” he said. “This shifts taxes from the wealthy to the middle class, full stop.”

Advertisement
A person handing another a ten-dollar bill.

Source: Karolina Grabowska/Pexels

However, there is a catch for people who are middle-income earners and a bit of a reward for high-income earners.

Advertisement

Higher Tax Rates for Low-Income Earners

Millions of US households earn less than $168,000 a year and would likely face high tax rates under Project 2025. Currently, the bottom half of American taxpayers, who earn less than $46,000 a year, pay a tax rate of 3.3%.

Advertisement
A woman looks over her bills, clearly stressed

Source: Freepik

This reflects their income taxes after deductions, tax credits, and other benefits. Paying 15% would be almost impossible for these taxpayers.

Advertisement

Impact on Middle-Class Families

The proposed tax changes could have significant implications for middle-class families. For example, a family earning $100,000 annually could see their taxes increase by $2,600 due to the loss of lower tax brackets.

Advertisement
Family Unpacking After Moving

Source: cottonbro studio/Pexels

The potential elimination of the Child Tax Credit would further increase their tax burden by an additional $6,600.

Advertisement

Higher Taxes for the Middle Class

Low-income taxpayers are not the only ones who will be paying the government to stay improvised. The higher tax on the middle class, along with the increase from removing tax credits, could wipe out the middle class.

Advertisement
Photo Of Man Holding Black Eyeglasses

Source: Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

“That 15% bracket is a very big deal in terms of raising taxes on middle-class families,” Duke said.

Advertisement

Benefits for High-Income Earners

In contrast, high-income earners would benefit from the proposed tax changes. A married couple with two children earning $5 million a year could receive a tax cut of $325,000.

Advertisement
A man is pictured holding a large sum of American bills

Source: Freepik

Critics argue that this shift would disproportionately benefit the wealthy at the expense of middle- and lower-income families.

Advertisement

Corporate and Capital Gains Tax Cuts

Project 2025 also proposes reducing the corporate tax rate from 21% to 18% and lowering the capital gains tax to 15%.

Advertisement
Some tax papers next to a notepad and pen.

Source: Olga DeLawrence/Unsplash

These changes aim to stimulate business investment and economic growth but have sparked debates about their long-term effects on income inequality.

Advertisement

Eliminating Green Energy Credits

Another controversial aspect of Project 2025 is the plan to eliminate credits for green energy projects created by the Inflation Reduction Act.

Advertisement
solar panels against backdrop of sky and trees

Source: Freepik

This move is intended to reduce government spending but could impact the progress of renewable energy initiatives and climate change mitigation efforts.

Advertisement

A Tax for Being “Childless”

Project 2025 seems to be taxing families that are not eligible for the child tax credit. In a recently resurfaced 2021 interview, Ohio Sen. JD Vance, the Republican nominee for vice president, suggested that Americans without children should be taxed at a higher rate than those with children.

Advertisement
A person holding a newborn baby’s feet.

Source: Omar Lopez/Unsplash

However, Vance’s stance disparaging “childless” Americans is widely popular among those supporting him.

Advertisement

The Push for a National Sales Tax

The blueprint considers introducing a national sales tax as a potential U.S. consumption tax.

Advertisement
Woman Working at Cash Register

Source: Mizuno K/ Pexels

This proposal suggests shifting the tax burden from income to consumption, although it raises concerns about the regressive nature of sales taxes on lower-income households.

Advertisement

Changes to the Federal Reserve’s Mandate

Project 2025 also recommends eliminating the Federal Reserve’s mandate to maintain full employment.

Advertisement
A photograph of the entrance to the U.S. Federal Reserve building

Source: iStock

This shift could lead to a narrower focus on controlling inflation, potentially affecting labor market stability and employment rates.

Advertisement

Political Feasibility and Legislative Hurdles

Implementing these tax reforms would require significant legislative changes, which could be challenging if Congress is divided.

Advertisement
Lawyer fills out paperwork on a desk with a judges gavel beside him

Source: Freepik

The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act passed with Republican control but no Democratic support, highlighting the difficulties of bipartisan agreement on tax policies.

Advertisement

Trump’s Distancing and Alternative Proposals

Former President Trump has distanced himself from Project 2025, emphasizing his own “Agenda 47” instead.

Advertisement
A photograph of Donald Trump on stage at an event

Source: Wikimedia

His proposals focus more on social and political issues, with less emphasis on tax reforms.

Advertisement

Extending Tax Cuts for Some

Trump has not proposed any concrete tax plans on his campaign trail, but analysts expect him to extend the tax cuts enacted through the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act if he wins reelection.

Advertisement
A photograph of Donald Trump as President

Source: Wikimedia

The TCJA was an overhaul of the federal tax code in 2017 that reformed individual and business pax.

Advertisement

A Tariff to Eliminate Federal Income Tax

A report from Oxford Economics (via CBS News) proposes that if Trump is reelected, he may extend the TJCA’s tax cuts, potentially repealing some of the clean energy and climate-related provisions in the Biden administration’s Inflation Reduction Act.

Advertisement
A close-up of a few hundred dollar bills on a table.

Source: engin akyurt/Unsplash

Trump has also suggested a proposal that creates a 10% tariff for all imports and a 60% tariff for Chinese imports. He believes this could raise enough money to eliminate the federal income tax.

Advertisement

Leaning in Favor of a Consumption Tax

While not paying an income tax sounds nice, tax experts don’t believe this would ever be possible.

Advertisement
A close-up of many different American dollar bills.

Source: Blogging Guide/Unsplash

“A tariff is a consumption tax, and there is a throughline between [Project 2025’s] tax reform and what Trump has talked about, getting rid of taxes in favor of a consumption tax,” Duke noted.

Advertisement

Expert Opinions on Feasibility

Tax experts have raised concerns about the feasibility of Trump’s tariff proposal, noting that tariff revenue would be insufficient to replace the over $2 trillion generated annually by individual income taxes.

Advertisement
A calculator, a pen, glasses, and a post-in that reads “Tax Time” on top of several US tax forms

Source: Freepik

Consumers could also face higher prices for imported goods, further complicating the economic landscape.

Advertisement

Paying More for Goods

Consumers would likely have to pay more for imported goods, leading to the implementation of a higher federal tax on goods and services.

Advertisement
A photograph of a woman pictured shopping

Source: Freepik

If the tariff is implemented and income taxes are eliminated, the price of goods could double due to taxes, making inflation seem mild by comparison.

Advertisement

A Pivotal Moment for Tax Reform

Project 2025 represents a bold and contentious plan to overhaul the U.S. tax system. Its success depends on political will and legislative support.

Advertisement
Empty tax return papers on a table with a pen and a cup of coffee.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

As Americans consider the implications of these proposals, the debate over the best path forward for tax policy and economic growth will be a critical issue in the upcoming election.

Advertisement