Harris' 'Catchphrase' Under Fire
Giuliani’s criticism centers on Harris’ frequent use of the phrase “what can be unburdened by what has been.”
Source: Getty Images
This line, which Harris has used multiple times in her public speeches, has been a point of contention among Republican figures. What’s more, Giuliani’s interpretation of the phrase has taken the controversy to a new level.
Linking to Karl Marx
On his show, Giuliani suggested that Harris’ catchphrase has roots in Marxist theory. He claimed, “That’s pure Marxism. That comes from Karl Marx.”
Source: Unknown Author/Wikimedia Commons
Giuliani argued that the phrase implies a desire to erase history, which he associated with communist ideology.
Marxist Connections Explained
Giuliani pointed to Karl Marx’s writings, particularly The Communist Manifesto and The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, to support his claims.
Source: John Jabez Edwin Mayal/Wikimedia Commons
He suggested that Marx’s ideas promote moving on from the past to achieve communism. The interpretation is a bit of a stretch, though, with its lack of concrete evidence.
Giuliani's Harsh Words
In his critique, Giuliani did not hold back, calling Harris either “stupid, brain injured, or a communist.”
Source: Wikimedia
He questioned whether Harris was even aware of the Marxist implications he suggested.
The Impact of Giuliani's Comments
Giuliani’s accusations have added fuel to the ongoing political debate.
Source: Gage Skidmore/Wikimedia
The timing of his criticism, coinciding with Harris’ nomination as the Democratic presidential candidate, has only intensified the conversation.
Harris' Rise to Nomination
Despite the controversy, Kamala Harris has continued to rise in the political arena.
Source: @VP, X
On Monday night, she secured enough delegate support to clinch the Democratic Party’s presidential nomination.
The Role of History in Politics
Giuliani’s comments also touched on the broader issue of how history is viewed and utilized in politics. He argued against the idea of forgetting the past, emphasizing the importance of historical events such as the American Revolution and the Civil War.
Source: Wikimedia
This, however, is likely a tactic in political rhetoric, more than a genuine concern for historical events repeating.
Giuliani's Own Controversial History
It is worth noting that Giuliani himself has a controversial history, notably his involvement in President Trump’s impeachment scandal.
Source: Wikimedia
Again, it could be argued that his criticism of Harris could also be seen as a political strategy to discredit her.
The Future of the 2024 Election
As the 2024 presidential election approaches, incidents like Giuliani’s comments are likely to continue shaping the political landscape.
Source: Wikimedia
Harris’ ability to navigate such comments (which are far from over) will be crucial to her campaign.
Moving Forward
Despite the drama, the focus remains on the upcoming election and the policies that each candidate will bring to the table.
Source: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Harris’ campaign will likely continue to emphasize her vision for the future, while Giuliani’s comments serve as a reminder of the intense scrutiny faced by public figures.
For the Voters
As Giuliani’s comments have shown, there will always be differing perspectives and interpretations of historical events and how they fit into the modern-day conversation.
Source: Freepik
Ultimately, it is up to us as citizens to critically examine them and make informed decisions about our leaders, proactively wading through the nastier side of politics.