Scientists Finally Answer the Question: Why Don’t Humans Have Tails?

By: Beth Moreton | Published: Mar 10, 2024

The theory of evolution states that humans originated from apes, who have tails. However, humans are tailless.

This has often led to many questions as to why humans don’t have tails. But a recent scientific discovery may now be able to answer and explain this burning question.

Darwin’s Theory of Evolution

Darwin’s theory of evolution states that any living organisms have come from similar species, but with modifications. (via PBS)

Advertisement
A cartoon version of evolution. It features six forms, from apes, all the way up to humans today.

Source: Stadtpflaenzchen/Wikimedia Commons

Darwin’s theory speculated that humans have evolved from apes, but one thing it didn’t explain was why humans are without tails.

Humans Becoming Tailless Happened 25 Million Years Ago

Humans being tailless isn’t a recent phenomenon and is believed to have occurred around 25 million years ago.

Advertisement
Three versions of evolution, from apes to humans today.

Source: Magnetic Hyena/Wikimedia Commons

This is when apes are believed to have evolved from monkeys, with homo sapiens first appearing 300,000 years ago.

One Mutation Changed Everything

Scientists have recently been looking into why apes have tails but humans don’t, and it turns out it was all down to one genetic mutation.

Advertisement
A skeletal look at human evolution, from being apes to being humans. The earlier version has long arms, hands, face, and feed, but the latest version is shorter on those features but has a straighter spine.

Source: Haeckel, Ernst Heinrich Phillip August/Wikimedia Commons

The findings were published in Nature Journal. One of the geneticists working on the study said they found “a single mutation in a very important gene.”

Different Species of Apes Were Studied

To look into why humans don’t have tails but apes do, researchers studied six species of apes, humans, and fifteen species of monkeys.

Advertisement
An photo of a monkey in a tree with green leaves.

Source: Treysam/Wikimedia Commons

They looked at the differences between all of them, and once they found a significant gene mutation, they used the gene-editing tool CRISPR to tweak the same gene in mouse embryos.

The DNA Wasn’t Present in Monkeys

The key to the study was including monkeys, as well as apes, because monkeys have tails, whereas apes do not.

Advertisement
A Red Howler monkey sitting between tree branches with a blue sky in the background.

Source: Garst Warren/Wikimedia Commons

This was how the geneticists were able to find the relevant DNA to prove their theory, because the gene that causes monkeys to have tails isn’t going to be present in humans, according to WION.

Advertisement

Mice Helped Prove Their Theory

By editing the genes in mice to test for which gene might have caused humans to not have tails, the scientists were able to prove their theory.

Advertisement
A mouse in a wooded, leafy area.

Source: Celestin Billeter/Wikimedia Commons

What happened when the mice were born was that tweaking this specific gene caused them to be born without tails, therefore proving the theory of why humans don’t have tails. (via AP News)

Advertisement

The DNA Changes Aren’t Due to Mutation

Where many theories have stated that genes have mutated over time, this recent study went against that.

Advertisement
An example of a gene, with various components, including two exons and an intron

Source: National Human Genome Research Institute/Wikimedia Commons

The study found that a genetic code snippet known as AluY had previously been inserted into an early version of humans in pre-historic times.

Advertisement

The Findings Aren’t Necessarily the Answer

While this might be a major step forward in terms of figuring out why humans don’t have tails, the findings from the study don’t necessarily mean they’re accurate.

Advertisement
An example of different skeletons of various species, which are gibbons, humans, chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans.

Source: TimVickers/Wikimedia Commons

Bo Xia, one of the geneticists involved in the study, stated there could have been other genetic changes that caused humans to lose their tails, but the findings at least offer one possible explanation.

Advertisement

Not Having Tails Might Have Helped Humans Survive

Another theory on the back of this one is that humans not having tails has helped them survive.

Advertisement
Some figures that showcase human evolution. These are cavemen and they are standing near rocks and green leaves.

Source: Biswarup Ganguly/Wikimedia Commons

Miriam Konkel, a geneticist, also states in the study that not having a tail could have given humans a genetic advantage in terms of survival, but this isn’t a certainty.

Advertisement

Darwin’s Theory of Evolution Supports the Human Survival Theory

One part of Darwin’s Theory of Evolution is natural selection, whereby some variants of a species are better able to survive than others, due to certain genetic traits.

Advertisement
An example of human evolution. It starts with homo habilis, then homo erectus, and finally, homo neanderthales.

Source: National Geographic/YouTube

Due to this, one likely theory as to why humans were a version of apes to survive is because of not having tails, which may also be why humans can now walk upright.

Advertisement

Tails on Land Are a Liability

Monkeys living in trees and having tails is helpful, as it helps them move between and grab onto trees.

Advertisement
A drawing of four different evolutions of humans. The second one has a tail.

Source: Encyclopædia/Wikimedia Commons

However, as humans have no use for tails on land, having one would end up as more of a liability. (via The Independent)

Advertisement

The Theory Explains Neural Tube Defects

Not only does this recent discovery prove why humans don’t have tails, but it also gives some suggestions as to why some humans have neural tube defects.

Advertisement
Versions of spina bifida. This includes a normal spine, occulta, meningoselli, and miyelomeningoselli.

Source: Mirana Gavami/Wikimedia Commons

Neural tube defects can cause diseases like spina bifida, where the spine doesn’t properly align with the spinal cord, but it will take further studies to prove this.

Advertisement