Tim Walz Facing Additional ‘Stolen valor’ Criticisms

By: Stephanie Bontorin | Published: Aug 13, 2024

The former battalion commander of Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz who led the Minnesota Army National Guard unit, sent out a statement on the accusations that he is guilty of “stolen valor.”

Rumors have been swirling lately that Walz has misinterpreted some of his time in service claims. From weapons of war to deployment, see where Walz’s truths line up.

The Statement

Kohn Kolb sent out the message on Facebook in an attempt to get the truth out about the current VP nominee.

Advertisement
A group of soldiers wearing camo walking out of a doorway with high walls and barbed wire

Source: @SRAlsultani/X

“I do not regret that Tim Walz retired early from the Minnesota National Guard, did not complete the Sergeants Major Academy, broke his enlistment contract or did not successfully complete any assignment as a Sergeant Major. Unwittingly, he got out of the way for better leadership.”

Who Is John Kolb?

John Kolb served as a lieutenant colonel of the 1st Ballation, 125th Field Artillery from the years 2005 to 2007, as reported by the Daily Mail.

Advertisement
A man wearing a military uniform standing with a woman with short hair

Source: @CollinRugg/X

Walz allegedly served in the same battalion unit until 2005, when he retired after serving his country for 24 years.

What Does the National Guard Do?

The National Guard is an honored arm of the United States military. Their primary function is to “answer the call, at home or abroad.”

Advertisement
Two soldiers walking in front of the Washington Monument and pool

Source: Koshu Kunii/Unsplash

The National Guard’s versatility enables its troops to respond quickly to domestic and international emergencies, combat missions, counterdrug efforts, reconstruction missions, and more. Some of the biggest tasks that they take part in are disaster relief and military support. Soldiers in these units are often seen as indispensable backup.

Walz's Military History

Walz first enlisted in the Nebraska National Guard until on April 8, 1981, two days after he turned 17. In 1996, he was transferred to the Minnesota National Guard, where he spent time in the 1st Battalion, 125th Filed Artillery until until he retired in May of 2005.

Advertisement
Tim Walz’s army portrait from 1981, with the US flag behind him.

Source: US Army/Wikimedia Commons

Minnesota Public Radio reported that part of his service was spent responding to floods and tornadoes when cities needed additional military support. He specialized in heavy artillery and was recognized for his proficiency in sharp shooting and hand grenades.

Overseas Deployment

Although Walz never spent time inside an active war zone, he was deployed overseas.

Advertisement
A group of soldiers walk out of a warehouse carrying guns

Source: FoToArtist/Canva Pro

On August 3, 2003, Walz and his battalion members were sent to Italy to support United States operations in Afghanistan under Operation Enduring Freedom. He returned to Minnesota in April 2004.

Advertisement

Walz Corrects Statements About Military Service

Although the official Harris and Walz campaign has only been active for a few weeks, there have already been enough events for pages worth of history books.

Advertisement
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz smiling

Source: Stephen Maturen/Getty Images

Just a few days ago, Walz was forced to correct a statement that he previously made about “weapons of war that I carried in war.” The original video was taken in 2018, and after being accused of lying about his service, Walz clarified that he did specialize in weapons as part of the artillery battalion but never saw an active combat zone.

Advertisement

Criticism for Stolen Valor

Kolb’s statements reiterate the idea that Tim Walz is guilty of using stolen valor to inflate his active military service.

Advertisement
Tim Walz giving a speech at the state fair in 2022

Source: Office of Governor Tim Walz & Lt. Governor Peggy Flanagan/Wikimedia Commons

One of the criticisms includes calling himself a “retired Command Sergeant Major.” When he retired from the National Guard, he earned this rank, but it was reduced months later to Master Sergeant as he did not complete the coursework associated with the U.S. Army Sergeants Major Academy.

Advertisement

Kolb's Further Remarks on Walz's Service

Kolb continued his scathing attack on social media by bringing up the changes in rank title despite what he says was “returning early” before his battalion was deployed to Iraq. At the time, Walz would have been 42 years old.

Advertisement
A large artillery machine

Source: Boris Busorgin/Unsplash

“By all accounts and on the record, he was a competent Chief of Firing Battery/Gunnery Sergeant and First Sergeant. I cannot say the same of his service sitting, frocked, in the CSM [command sergeant major] chair. He did not earn the rank or successfully complete any assignment as an E9,” Kolb wrote.

Advertisement

A Change in Career

“He did not earn the rank or successfully complete any assignment as an E9. It is an affront to the Noncommissioned Officer Corps that he continues to glom onto the title. I can sit in the cockpit of an airplane; it does not make me a pilot. Similarly, when the demands of service and leadership at the highest level got real, he chose another path.”

Advertisement
Tim Walz while he was in the army. He is wearing an army uniform and holding a gun.

Source: @vivalaradicals/X

By the time Walz retired, he had already gone to university, earned a degree, married, and worked as a teacher and a football coach in Minnesota. He was 42 years old when he retired and began his ascent into politics the next year.

Advertisement

What Is Stolen Valor?

Stolen valor has a real legal definition but also has a broader social meaning.

Advertisement
A United States military award

Source: Tim Mossholder/Unsplash

The idea refers to a person making false claims about military service, mostly related to medals awarded in combat.

Advertisement

What Benefit Could Walz Be Getting?

One might think that in 24 years of service, Walz could have gained the necessary military experience, leadership skills, and a sense of duty to his country.

Advertisement
Kamala Harris and Tim Walz in Philadelphia. Harris is standing behind a lectern with microphones, and Walz is behind her. A crowd is behind them holding blue “Harris Walz” signs.

Source: @KamalaHarris/X

Critics claim that lying and misinterpreting his service could potentially sway voters, namely veterans.

Advertisement