What Do We Know About the Real ‘Braveheart’ William Wallace?

By: Georgia McKoy | Published: Mar 09, 2024

William Wallace, a figure shrouded in mystery and legend, emerged in the late 13th century as a pivotal leader in the First War of Scottish Independence.

Born into a family of lesser nobility in 1270, the details of his lineage remain unclear, with various sources offering conflicting information about his parents and place of birth. His father, named Alan Wallace in a letter dated 1297, is one of the few connections to his familial roots.

The Early Life of a Future Hero

Ancient Origins reveals that Wallace’s early life is largely undocumented, with historical records providing minimal information about his upbringing and family. It is suggested that he may have been born at Ellerslie, near Kilmarnock, Ayrshire, in Scotland, into a family with noble connections.

Advertisement
A deserted sandy beach stretches out with footprints dotting its surface

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Some historians speculate that his father was a knight and a vassal of James Stewart, 5th High Steward of Scotland, indicating a noble upbringing. However, the exact details of his family and early years remain a subject of debate among scholars.

The Unlikely Rise of a National Hero

Despite the obscure details of his early life, William Wallace would rise to become a symbol of Scottish independence.

Advertisement
This image features a detailed engraving of William Wallace, depicted with a stern expression. He is wearing a helmet adorned with a decorative plume and chainmail armor

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Wallace’s ability to rally the Scots and lead them in battle against a powerful adversary speaks to his charisma and strategic prowess. Ancient Origins explains that his iconic status as “Braveheart” is a testament to his impact on Scottish history, yet the true story of his rise from lesser nobility to national hero is complex and nuanced, woven through with threads of legend and historical fact.

A Questionable Pedigree

Historical records offer little concrete evidence about Wallace’s family, leading to much speculation. According to a seal on a letter from 1297, his father was Alan Wallace, a figure about whom little is known.

Advertisement
A stained glass image portraying William Wallace in a historic setting. He is depicted with a stern, bearded face, wearing a chainmail coif and armor, with a sword slung over his shoulder

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This lack of information about his family background contributes to the mystique surrounding Wallace. The ambiguity of his origins, whether as a commoner or a noble, highlights the challenges historians face in separating the man from the myth.

Wallace's Entry into Rebellion

According to the National Wallace Monument, Wallace’s entry into the annals of Scottish history began with his defiance against English rule. In 1297, he led a successful raid against Lanark, killing the English sheriff William Heselrig. This act of rebellion was a turning point, marking Wallace’s emergence as a leader in the struggle for Scottish independence. 

Advertisement
The image is a detailed engraving depicting William Wallace in the midst of a battle scene. Wallace is portrayed at the forefront, leading a group of soldiers who are armed with shields and swords. He is pointing his sword forward

Source: Wikimedia Commons

His leadership in guerrilla warfare and subsequent raids across Scotland demonstrated his commitment to the cause and his skill as a military strategist.

The Battle of Stirling Bridge

The Battle of Stirling Bridge in September 1297 was a significant victory for Wallace and the Scottish forces. By employing superior tactics and taking advantage of the terrain, Wallace was able to defeat a much larger English army, Highland Titles reveals.

Advertisement
This detailed black and white engraving depicts the historic Battle of Stirling Bridge, with medieval soldiers engaged in fierce combat. In the foreground, a wooden bridge is overrun with warriors clashing swords and shields, while others are falling into the water below

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This victory not only boosted Scottish morale but also established Wallace as a formidable military leader.

Advertisement

Stirling Victory

According to Britannica, The English were forced to narrowly file on the bridge to successfully cross it. 

Advertisement
A photo of the Old Stirling Bridge in modern day.

Source: Annboeva.Wikimedia

Wallace waited until half the English troops had crossed before unleashing a devastating attack. The English commander, the Earl of Surrey was forced to make a hasty retreat, abandoning many of his men to be killed or drowned in the river.

Advertisement

Resuming Trade

Thanks to Wallace’s victory at Stirling, he was able to almost completely free Scotland of English occupation for the time being. 

Advertisement
A medieval cart being loaded.

Source: Wikimedia

Wallace collaborated on a letter sent to the Hanseatic towns of Hamburg and Lübeck confirming that the country had now recovered from the war with the English and that they could now resume trade relations. Britannica says the letter was written on October 11, 1297.

Advertisement

Wallace's Rampage Continues

William Wallace’s loyal forces’ fury was not quenched by the victory at Stirling Bridge. These forces would go on to attack the now-weakened areas that were under English protection. 

Advertisement
A medieval-style sword on a table.

Source: Jonathan Kemper/Unsplash

According to Britannica, Wallace attacks Northumberland and Cumberland. He also burned Alnwick and used his force to siege Carlise. Wallace reportedly spared the monks of Hexham, a town in Northumberland.

Advertisement

Wallace Knighted

When Wallace returned to Scotland after this string of victories in December 1297 he was reportedly knighted, according to Britannica

Advertisement
A dark William Wallace statue by green trees and an old building in Aberdeen.

Source: Public Domain/Wikimedia Commons

Although it was reported that he was knighted, it is not known who exactly bestowed the honor on him. Although who knighted him is unknown he had gained the favor of important supporters like Robert Wishart, Bishop of Glasgow, and Robert the Bruce. 

Advertisement

Tricky Noble Support

Although Wallace’s victory had won him fame and approval of the residents of Scotland, many of the nobles were lukewarm to the rising star. Many of the nobles in Scotland still had connections to England in the form of English estates. 

Advertisement
Seal coins minted for Robert the Bruce.

Source: Wikimedia

Some according to Britannica, also had family or friends hostage in the hands of the English, meaning some of their loyalties were divided. The nobles would tolerate Wallace as a leader, but only as long as would keep winning battles.

Advertisement

Who Was Robert the Bruce?

Robert the Bruce was a critical ally to Wallace during the war for independence, eventually going on to become Scotland’s king in 1306 according to Smithsonian Magazine

Advertisement
A photo of a statue of Robert the Bruce.

Source: Kim Traynor/Wikimedia

Bruce was eventually excommunicated by the Pope for the murder of political rival John Comyn, only for him to later return to seize the throne.

Advertisement

Guardian of Scotland

Following the victory at Stirling Bridge, Wallace’s stature as a leader was solidified. He was appointed as a Guardian of Scotland, a role that recognized his contributions to the Scottish independence movement.

Advertisement
The left side of the image shows a stone statue of William Wallace standing solemnly in a niche, clad in traditional medieval armor, holding a sword, and bearing a shield. On the right, a detailed stone carving of the Scottish crest features a rampant lion within a shield, surrounded by decorative elements including foliage and a ribbon

Source: Wikimedia Commons

In this capacity, Wallace continued to lead military campaigns against English forces, further cementing his legacy as a champion of Scottish freedom. His leadership during this period was crucial in maintaining the momentum of the independence movement.

Advertisement

The Battle of Falkirk: A Turning Point

The Battle of Falkirk in 1298 marked a significant setback for Wallace and the Scottish forces. Despite his best efforts, Wallace’s army was defeated by the English, led by King Edward I. 

Advertisement
A pencil sketch showing portraits of William Wallace and King Edward I. On the left, a man is depicted with a furrowed brow, curly hair, and a full beard, while the man on the right is shown wearing a decorated headpiece with a similar beard and a solemn expression

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This defeat was a blow to Wallace’s campaign and led to his resignation as Guardian of Scotland. 

Advertisement

Wallace After Falkirk

After the defeat at Falkirk, Wallace’s role in the Scottish independence movement became less clear. While he no longer held the title of Guardian, he continued to be involved in the fight against English rule.

Advertisement
The image shows an aged image of a hand drawn map showing a plan for the Battle of Falkirk

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Ancient Origins points out that historical records during this period are sparse, leaving much of Wallace’s activities to speculation. Despite this, his commitment to the cause of Scottish independence remained undiminished, and he continued to be a symbol of resistance against English domination.

Advertisement

The Capture and Trial of William Wallace

The Scotsman reports that in 1305, Wallace was captured and handed over to the English. His trial in London was a highly charged affair, where he was charged with treason and atrocities against civilians. 

Advertisement
This painting captures a vibrant historical scene inside a royal court. The central figure, possibly a king or nobleman, stands with authority, surrounded by various courtiers and warriors in richly colored garments. To the right, a group of figures engages in a discussion, while a man in red gestures emphatically. The left side shows soldiers and dignitaries in elaborate dress

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Wallace defended himself by claiming he had never sworn allegiance to Edward, saying, “I  can not be a traitor, for I owe him no allegiance. He is not my Sovereign; he never received my homage; and whilst life is in this persecuted body, he never shall receive it.” Despite his defense, he was found guilty and subjected to a brutal execution, intended to quash the spirit of Scottish resistance.

Advertisement

The Execution of Wallace

Wallace’s execution on August 23, 1305, was designed to be a spectacle of deterrence, featuring hanging, disembowelment, and quartering. His remains were displayed in various parts of England and Scotland as a warning to others.

Advertisement
The photograph shows a close-up of the base of a monument dedicated to William Wallace, with the name 'WALLACE' prominently inscribed in the stone. Centered below is a sculpted Scottish lion rampant crest, etched into the stone

Source: Wikimedia Commons

However, this act of brutality had the opposite effect, galvanizing the Scottish resistance and immortalizing Wallace as a martyr for the cause of independence. His death became a rallying point for the Scottish people, inspiring further rebellion against English rule.

Advertisement

The Legacy of William Wallace

The Scotsman highlights that despite the passage of time, William Wallace’s legacy as a symbol of Scottish independence endures. His life and sacrifices have been memorialized in literature, film, and monuments, celebrating his role in Scotland’s history.

Advertisement
A photograph of the National Wallace Monument, a tall and slender tower rising above a lush green forest under a dramatic sky

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The National Wallace Monument in Stirling stands as a testament to his enduring legacy, a reminder of the struggle for freedom and the price of resistance.

Advertisement